Songs in Therapy: Hurt

Songs in Therapy: Hurt

This is a fictional psychodynamic exploration inspired by the emotional world of the song Hurt. The character and therapeutic encounter are imagined, and are not intended as factual representations of any artist or individual.

Pain as Proof

Elias sits with one sleeve pulled low over part of his hand despite the warmth of the room. He has the tired posture of someone accustomed to carrying discomfort privately, as though even his suffering should remain careful not to inconvenience anyone else. When he speaks about hurting himself, he does so quietly, almost matter-of-factly. Afterwards, a faint smile appears, though it feels less like reassurance and more like habit — the reflex of someone trying to soften the impact of his own honesty before another person has time to react to it fully. Neither of us speaks immediately afterwards. Rain moves softly against the window behind him.

“It’s not always that,” he says eventually. “Sometimes it’s drinking. Sometimes substances. Sometimes I just make things worse for myself on purpose.”

He keeps looking towards the floor.

“It all ends in the same place anyway.”

The sentence lingers in the room. Elias speaks about self-destruction without excitement, rebellion, or self-pity. If anything, he sounds exhausted by it. The hurting no longer feels impulsive. It feels familiar. Like a private ritual that has slowly become woven into the structure of his life.

“I don’t think I’m trying to enjoy myself,” he says after a while.

“What are you trying to do?”

This time he takes longer before answering.

“I think I’m trying to feel something arrive.”

His thumb presses slowly against the fabric covering his wrist.

“I hurt myself today.”

Over time, it becomes difficult not to notice the emotional logic beneath the behaviour. Elias often speaks about himself as though he exists slightly outside his own life, observing it rather than fully inhabiting it. Some mornings he wakes with the exhausted feeling that the world has moved further away overnight. People speak to him. He responds. He goes to work. He laughs in the right places. But underneath it all there remains a persistent flatness, as though something essential has gone numb inside him.

Pain interrupts that numbness briefly enough to remind him he is still there.

One afternoon he describes leaving somebody’s flat while the streets were still dark outside. The story arrives slowly, through fragments rather than detail — too much alcohol, substances passed around casually, music playing too loudly somewhere in the background. Halfway through speaking, he stops.

“The whole thing felt horrible while it was happening,” he says quietly. Headlights move briefly across the ceiling as a car turns outside.

“But afterwards I felt calmer.”

Neither of us speaks immediately. Elias keeps staring at the floor, his thumb pressing slowly against the fabric covering his wrist.

“Like it matched for a bit,” he says eventually.

“What matched?”

He shrugs faintly.

“How I felt anyway.”

His hand tightens slightly beneath the sleeve.

“The needle tears a hole.”

The Shape of Shame

His father enters the room gradually over the weeks that follow. Not through dramatic memories or obvious cruelty, but through smaller things. School reports. Conversations in kitchens. Advice about work. Questions about money. Remarks that stayed longer than they were perhaps intended to.

“He’s a good man,” Elias says one evening. “Honestly. He’s always been there.” The loyalty in his voice is immediate. Then comes the pause.

“I just never really knew when he was proud of me.”

Outside, rainwater moves slowly down the glass.

Elias speaks about his father carefully, as though trying to remain fair. He describes a quiet, introverted man who worked hard, worried often, and showed care through practical things rather than emotional language. Concern frequently arrived disguised as advice. Advice often carried disappointment hidden somewhere inside it.

At school, teachers would say Elias had potential. His father agreed. The phrase should have sounded encouraging. Instead, it left him with the feeling that another version of himself existed nearby — a version that made better decisions, worked harder, caused less concern.

“There was always another me in the room,” Elias says quietly. His eyes remain lowered. “One he would’ve understood more easily.”

Elias did not grow up unloved. That is what makes the sadness harder for him to justify inside himself. He has no simple story explaining why he feels so damaged. No obvious wound he can point towards cleanly. Instead, the shame seems to have gathered slowly over years, settling into him quietly until it became difficult to separate from his sense of self. Now, disappointment no longer needs another person to deliver it. The voice has become internal. This emerges most painfully when he speaks about his body. Mirrors exhaust him. Photographs can ruin entire days. He studies himself with the uneasy concentration of someone searching for evidence.

“It isn’t even that I think I’m ugly,” he says once. “It’s more like…” The room waits with him. “Like something’s wrong underneath it.” He looks away almost immediately afterwards. Not embarrassed by vanity. Embarrassed by exposure. Some mornings, he says, he catches sight of himself unexpectedly and feels a sudden wave of disgust he cannot fully explain. Not because of one specific feature. More the feeling that something internally damaged has somehow become visible through the surface of him.

“What have I become?”

The question hangs heavily in the room. Not dramatic.

Frightened.

Later, while speaking about another night spent drinking too much, Elias suddenly stops halfway through the sentence. “I think people can tell eventually,” he says quietly.

“Tell what?” A long pause follows.

“That there’s something not right about me.” Silence settles around the words. Not empty silence.

Thinking silence.

The Girl Who Stayed

Her name enters the room long before Elias says it aloud. At first, it is a song he heard unexpectedly in a shop near the station. Then a street he no longer likes walking down after dark. Then an old message he says he found “by accident” while searching for something else on his phone. The relationship lasted less than a year. He was sixteen when it began. Seventeen when it ended. Still, she remains present in him with the emotional weight of something far larger.

“She moved on quickly,” he says one evening. No bitterness follows the sentence. That feels important. If anything, he sounds protective of her still.

“She seems happy.”

The words are simple, but something in him folds slightly around them after they leave his mouth. Outside, somebody laughs faintly somewhere further down the corridor before the sound disappears again. Elias keeps looking towards his hands.

“I think part of me always thought she’d come back.” Not because he fully believes it now. Something quieter than belief seems involved. He still notices songs she used to like. Still remembers small details he pretends no longer matter. Certain places in the city feel emotionally altered because she once existed there beside him. Sometimes he checks things he knows he should stop checking. Not obsessively. Just enough to keep her emotionally alive somewhere in the background of his life.

“You are someone else,” he says softly one evening, almost to himself. Then, after a pause:

“I’m still right here.” The room feels unusually still after that.

At times, it seems less like Elias misses the girl herself and more like he misses the self he briefly became while being loved by her. A softer self. A chosen self. Someone less organised around shame. Without the relationship, something older returned. The expectation that closeness eventually fades. That love leaves. That people move towards brighter versions of life while he somehow remains emotionally where they left him.

“Everyone I know goes away in the end.”

The words do not sound angry. They sound resigned.

One evening, while speaking about a recent relationship that lasted only a few weeks, Elias gives a faint laugh and says, “I spend most of my life wanting people close to me.” He stops. “Then when they are, I want to disappear.” The contradiction remains between us quietly. He wants closeness deeply. This becomes obvious long before he admits it directly. But closeness also threatens exposure. To be truly seen means risking confirmation of everything he already fears privately about himself. The more emotionally near someone becomes, the harder it is for him to believe they will stay. At times, he seems to prepare for abandonment before intimacy has properly begun.

When Beauty Hurts

Some of the most exposed moments in the room arrive unexpectedly. One afternoon Elias describes walking home while listening to music just as the evening light was fading through the trees near his street.

“It sounds stupid,” he says quietly, “but beautiful things actually hurt me sometimes.”

“What kind of beautiful things?”

He shrugs lightly. “A song. Certain films. My dog sometimes.” This time the smile that appears lasts slightly longer. “He sleeps beside me every night like I’m not difficult to love.” Something softens in the room after he says it. Until then, Elias has mostly spoken about himself through shame, exhaustion, disappointment, and damage. But tenderness enters differently. It catches him off guard. He laughs awkwardly afterwards, almost embarrassed by the emotion in his own voice.

Certain songs seem to reach Elias before other people do. They follow him through train journeys, empty mornings, nights he cannot sleep, walks home after drinking too much. He speaks about music less as entertainment and more as recognition. “Some songs feel like they know things about me before I do,” he says once. Rain presses softly against the glass again.

“But I remember everything.”

Memory does not arrive neatly for Elias. It returns through atmosphere. A smell. A line from a song. The colour of evening light. The sound of someone closing a door. The feeling of waiting for a message that never comes. Everything seems connected to everything else. This is why beauty hurts him. Not because it reminds him only of sadness, but because it briefly reconnects him with feeling itself. Music, tenderness, memory, light — these moments expose the part of him that remains emotionally alive beneath all the numbness.

And feeling alive means feeling loss too.

The Broken Thoughts

There are evenings where Elias arrives already exhausted by his own mind. His thoughts seem to move in circles late into the night, returning repeatedly to old conversations, regrets, photographs, imagined futures, mistakes he cannot stop revisiting. Some mornings he looks worn down before the day has properly begun, as though he has spent hours wrestling privately with something that refuses to settle.

“I overthink everything,” he says one evening. Then he smiles faintly. “At least that’s what everyone tells me.” But it feels larger than overthinking. Elias often speaks as though his mind has become something he must survive rather than inhabit comfortably. Certain thoughts repeat until they lose clear shape. Shame attaches itself to memories and refuses to let go. He revisits moments long after they are finished, searching for where things changed, where people drifted, where he failed. At times, even he seems tired of hearing himself think.

“Full of broken thoughts I cannot repair.” The words settle into the room with quiet accuracy.

Not because Elias believes himself beyond help, but because he no longer trusts his own mind to hold things together gently. Every feeling seems to become tangled with another feeling. Love with grief. Hope with shame. Intimacy with fear. Tenderness with loss.

Nothing stays simple inside him for long.

The Fear of Hurting Others

One evening Elias arrives quieter than usual. The session moves slowly at first. Long silences. Half-finished thoughts. He keeps rubbing his thumb against the edge of the sleeve without seeming aware of it. Eventually he says, “I think I ruin people a bit.” The sentence lands carefully between us.

“What makes you think that?”

He stares towards the floor.

“I don’t know.” A pause. “I just think if people get too close to me eventually they end up unhappy.” His voice remains calm while saying it, which somehow makes it sadder. Not self-pitying.

Convinced.

He speaks about relationships as though disappointment is already waiting inside them before they properly begin. Even when someone moves towards him emotionally, part of him seems to prepare quietly for the moment he will fail them somehow.

“I will let you down.”

The room remains silent. Then, softer still:

“I will make you hurt.”

Elias closes his eyes briefly after saying it. For a moment, he looks less like somebody afraid of being abandoned and more like somebody afraid of becoming the reason people leave.

Starting Again

Over time, the sadness begins to feel less like an emotion Elias experiences and more like somewhere he lives. It shapes the music he trusts, the people he moves towards, the way he sees his own body, the way he waits for disappointment before it arrives. Without it, he no longer seems fully certain who he would be.

One evening he sits quietly for a long time before speaking.

“I don’t really know who I’d be without it.”

“Without what?”

This time the answer comes almost immediately.

“The sadness.”

Outside, headlights move briefly across the ceiling before disappearing again. Elias keeps staring towards his hands. “It’s been there so long.” There is no drama in the sentence. That is what makes it painful. At times, the sadness seems to function almost like identity itself. It gives shape to things. Continuity. Familiarity. Even meaning. To let go of it too quickly might feel like betraying something — the girl, the years, the pain, the version of himself that survived by carrying it.

“I wear this crown of thorns.”

The words settle heavily into the silence between us. Not performance. Something closer to recognition.

Near the end of one session, Elias speaks quietly while still looking down. “If I could start again…” The sentence trails away before finishing. Neither of us interrupts it. For several moments, the room remains completely still. Then Elias gives a faint smile, tired but real.

“I don’t even know what that would look like.” The sadness is still there. The shame too. The longing, the exhaustion, the fear of being too damaged to remain loved. None of it disappears neatly. But something else remains alive alongside it.

The dog waiting at the door.
The music.
The wish to feel something arrive.
The fact he keeps returning to the room each week despite everything in him that wants to retreat.

Somewhere underneath the sadness, something continues quietly beside it. Something stubborn enough to keep searching for contact even now.

“I would find a way.”

Link to “Hurt” performed by Johnny Cash

https://youtu.be/8AHCfZTRGiI?list=RD8AHCfZTRGiI&t=31

Is therapy for me?

If therapy feels like something you may wish to explore, you are welcome to take your time looking through the site, reading more about how I work, and learning more about psychodynamic counselling itself.

This piece is the first in a monthly series exploring the emotional and psychological world of music through a psychodynamic lens, and how songs can sometimes express feelings that are difficult to put into words alone.